You voted:

(2) comments

Deb L

This poll question, itself, is inaccurate. There was no chant of "throw her out" by some random N.C. crowd. The actual chant was "Send her back", and it wasn't chanted by some random N.C. crowd. It was a crowd that had gathered for a Trump rally in N.C. -- and, they were following the lead and words of Donald Trump's racist tweet about Cong. Omar and 3 other freshman Congresswomen of color. The President's twitter feed and other history is filled with racism like this, and this chant was parroting that racism against an American citizen and duly-elected member of Congress. It's not only this mangled question in the poll that's inaccurate/lacking; the two choices offered as responses equally miss the point. To ignore or soft-pedal the issue of racism -- something done regularly by this paper's editorial writers -- lets readers in this overwhelmingly Trump-supporting county off the hook. Don't allow readers to simply blame generalized, random "mob mentality, hostility" -- force them to deal with the explicit racism of the President's actual words. Be explicit about the fact that his racist tweet inspired a racist chant, and he was just fine with that as he silently basked in the echoing chant for 13 seconds, while it shamelessly reverberated around the auditorium in North Carolina. The President's strategy for reelection is loud and clear -- create as much hate and division as possible, and leave no racist trope behind. https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-trumps-washington/im-winning-donald-trumps-calculated-racism Republicans and their apologists need to quit dancing around the edges of this reality: Trump is a racist -- he has proven this over and over again. (https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/01/15/opinion/leonhardt-trump-racist.html A more interesting poll question might be: "As a Republican, or Trumpublican, which most closely identifies your reason for excusing Trump's racism: 1) The stock market has been great for me, and I always, and only, vote my pocketbook; 2) Trump changed his mind about abortion, cynically trading his judge picks for my vote; as long as he maintains this bargain, and will appoint judges who agree with my religious beliefs, he has my vote ; 3) "I know you are, but what am I?!" in other words, I'm uncomfortable with my racism and choose to use the age-old counter of turning the charge of racism back on the victims; 4) there's nothing wrong with "white pride", and the President is just "keeping it real" and defending America's white, Christian race/tradition." But I digress. A good answer to the poll question, "How do you feel about the Trump rally crowd in North Carolina parroting the President's tweet, with the message 'Send her back'?" is written by 149 former Obama administration officials here: "We Are African Americans, We Are Patriots, And We Refuse to Sit Idly By" (Wash.Post, 7/26/19) "We’ve heard this before. Go back where you came from. Go back to Africa. And now, “send her back.” Black and brown people in America don’t hear these chants in a vacuum; for many of us, we’ve felt their full force being shouted in our faces, whispered behind our backs, scrawled across lockers, or hurled at us online. They are part of a pattern in our country designed to denigrate us as well as keep us separate and afraid. As 149 African Americans who served in the last administration, we witnessed firsthand the relentless attacks on the legitimacy of President Barack Obama and his family from our front-row seats to America’s first black presidency. Witnessing racism surge in our country, both during and after Obama’s service and ours, has been a shattering reality, to say the least. But it has also provided jet-fuel for our activism, especially in moments such as these. We stand with congresswomen Ilhan Omar, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Ayanna Pressley and Rashida Tlaib, as well as all those currently under attack by President Trump, along with his supporters and his enablers, who feel deputized to decide who belongs here — and who does not. There is truly nothing more un-American than calling on fellow citizens to leave our country — by citing their immigrant roots, or ancestry, or their unwillingness to sit in quiet obedience while democracy is being undermined. We are proud descendants of immigrants, refugees and the enslaved Africans who built this country while enduring the horrors of its original sin. We stand on the soil they tilled, and march in the streets they helped to pave. We are red-blooded Americans, we are patriots, and we have plenty to say about the direction this country is headed. We decry voter suppression. We demand equitable access to health care, housing, quality schools and employment. We welcome new Americans with dignity and open arms. And we will never stop fighting for the overhaul of a criminal-justice system with racist foundations. We come from Minnesota and Michigan. The Bronx and Baton Rouge. Florida and Philadelphia. Cleveland and the Carolinas. Atlanta and Nevada. Oak-town and the Chi. We understand our role in this democracy, and respect the promise of a nation built by, for and of immigrants. We are part of that tradition, and have the strength to both respect our ancestors from faraway lands and the country we all call home. Our love of country lives in these demands, and our commitment to use our voices and our energy to build a more perfect union. We refuse to sit idly by as racism, sexism, homophobia and xenophobia are wielded by the president and any elected official complicit in the poisoning of our democracy. We call on local, state and congressional officials, as well as presidential candidates to articulate their policies and strategies for moving us forward as a strong democracy, through a racial-equity lens that prioritizes people over profit. We will continue to support candidates for local, state and federal office who add more diverse representation to the dialogue and those who understand the importance of such diversity when policymaking here in our country and around the world. We ask all Americans to be a good neighbor by demonstrating anti-racist, environmentally friendly, and inclusive behavior toward everyone in your everyday interactions. The statesman Frederick Douglass warned, “The life of a nation is secure only while the nation is honest, truthful and virtuous.” This nation has neither grappled with nor healed from the horrors of its origins. It is time to advance that healing process now through our justice, economic, health and political systems. Expect to hear more from us. We plan to leave this country better than we found it. This is our home."


Deb L

Thank you for correcting the error in the first version of your poll question, which read:



"throw her out" rather than "send her back". Accuracy matters, especially in the age of Trump's constant lies, and his false accusations that media who don't kowtow to him are "fake news". https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/10/president-trump-has-made-false-or-misleading-claims-over-days/?utm_term=.f530dbbb7e14


Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.